Recent IT Outages Highlight Need for Better Coordination, Clear Performance Metrics
Recent federal IT outages are raising questions about coordination, system reliability and how agencies measure technology performance.
A series of technology outages across multiple critical infrastructure sectors is increasing scrutiny of how the federal government assesses contractor performance and maintains critical operations.
Technology disruptions emerged in quick succession last week, beginning with a Microsoft 365 outage and followed by a nationwide Federal Aviation Administration ground stop of domestic flights Nov. 13 due to technical issues with air traffic control systems.
On Monday, CNN reported that the National Security Agency’s internal communications network, NSANet, went down, with NSA officials attributing the outage, in a statement, to “scheduled routine maintenance.”
“While some internal systems were affected, mission-critical capabilities remain fully operational and our ability to defend national security continues. NSA’s infrastructure is designed with multiple layers of redundancy to maintain operations during planned maintenance or unexpected events,” NSA officials said.
In each of the instances, the outages occurred following either scheduled upgrades or modernization efforts, raising calls from some technology and contracting experts for more coordination between private and public sectors.
The Dual Mandate
Federal agencies face the dual challenge of modernizing their IT systems while maintaining the legacy infrastructure supporting critical operations, which often consumes the lion’s share of IT budgets.
“Roughly, we estimate that somewhere between 80% and 90% of all the money we spend every year on those kind of systems is spent on maintaining legacy systems. Only a small portion of it is spent on upgrades,” said David Berteau, a senior fellow at the National Academy of Public Administration (NAPA) and former government official. “And the reality is that that maintenance has to occur. That’s not something you say, ‘Well, we’ll skip the maintenance this year,’ or else you’re going to end up with real problems. And so you have a limited amount of time and money to spend on the upgrades.”
That challenge was apparent in Friday’s ground stop, which FAA officials said was caused by data flooding legacy equipment following the installation of new routers at two FAA sites.
Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy has since requested $50 billion in emergency funding to update air traffic control systems, while some in Congress have questioned the need for additional spending after the FAA has already received funding from the Big Beautiful Bill.
But to avoid scenarios like this, some experts are also calling for better coordination between agencies and contractors to bring awareness and transparency to the modernization process.
“I think you really need to have the kind of collaboration effort of everyone involved within the FAA ecosystem,” said Laura Crabtree, CEO of aerospace software management company Epsilon3. “So whether it be contractors, OEMs, FAA personnel and anyone in the greater ecosystem needs to have a centralized kind of hub of information where they find out what is happening on that day.”
Further complicating the issue is the federal government’s funding cycle, which requires long lead times and rigorous oversight of technology projects.
Cara LaPointe, director of analysis at Georgetown University’s Center for Security and Emerging Technology (CSET) and a former Navy director of strategic assessment, said managing the many factors involved in these systems requires a comprehensive, integrated approach from the outset.
“There’s no single lesson to be learned or single approach that’s going to help us do IT modernization well,” she said. “Some of the things we have to think about are the technology itself, but then the safety, assurance, how we do things like auditing and testing, the policy and governance that goes along with that. … So, to me, the big takeaway is that you really have to have a strategic and holistic approach to how you are addressing this issue. And it has to be approached with critical infrastructure in particular, you have to be having safety, security and this idea of continuous sustainment at the core of that.”
The Performance Issue
While the FAA outage highlights challenges integrating modernized and legacy systems, the Microsoft 365 disruption reflects a different problem for federal agencies: the cascading effects of an outage at a cloud service provider.
Federal agencies did not publicly disclose disruptions from the outage, but the U.S. House of Representatives and several international government entities reported service interruptions. Berteau said the outage highlights the need for the federal government to rethink how it measures contractor performance.
“This is important for federal planning for its programs, build in the performance you want, have the revenue associated with the contract based on those deliverables, and deliverables would basically be working all the time, or 99.999% of the time,” Berteau told GovCIO Media & Research prior to the NSA outage. “This is not impossible. The government does this, but it is hard for the government sometimes to agree on what performance it wants. Because everything can’t be tied for first place.”
He suggested that federal contracts for critical IT services include system uptime as a key performance metric.
“Upgrades, if they interfere with uptime, shouldn’t be rewarded,” he said. “Ultimately, what do we do when it’s life and death matters? We test the heck out of stuff before we upgrade. And that probably would apply to both of these cases here as well as many, many others.”
Pressure on federal IT systems to operate continuously while keeping pace with technological innovation is growing, and current funding structures are struggling to keep up.
Berteau added that while the Trump administration has sought to reform some acquisition policies, defining contract performance will have to be a consideration moving forward.
“How do you do this? Increase speed at the same time as you increase reliability? That’s the challenge,” he said. “You need the definition of performance to be clear, measurable and changeable as technology changes. I don’t see that built into these updates in procurement rules either in the Revolutionary [Federal Acquisition Regulation] overhaul, in the class deviation memos that have implemented those so far or in the Pentagon’s own modernization of its procurement system. That I think is the element. If it’s there, it’s not visible to me.”
This is a carousel with manually rotating slides. Use Next and Previous buttons to navigate or jump to a slide with the slide dots
-
FBI Warns of Growing Nation-State Threats to Quantum Research
FBI officials warn that foreign adversaries could target U.S. quantum advancements, prompting new efforts to protect research and critical technologies.
3m read -
5 Federal Tech Programs to Watch in 2027
These federal technology programs are reshaping how the government delivers on its mission.
5m read -
How Edge AI Is Shaping the Future of Federal Missions
HP's Leif Olson discussed how edge AI can help federal agencies strengthen security, control costs and improve mission efficiency.
9m watch -
AI Drives Cybersecurity Strategies Beyond Patching to Thwart Vulnerabilities
NinjaOne's Egon Rinderer discussed how AI-driven cyber threats are changing vulnerability management and why agencies need to move beyond patching.
20m watch